, the Clans subdivide R1b into several distinct pieces: what I call Picts, WAMH; Scottis; Ulster Scottis, and haplotypes like mine which is not only a 12 at 393, but a 23 at 390, a 13 at 388 and so on. RE: Columba, there are several "stories" of what happened - the truth is probably unknown. Refuting Jackson seems popular now, at one time he was highly respected - the climate of "truth" changes.I guess the broad picture Oppenheimer creates is one I also think is correct. To date we don't understand the SNP/STR data well enough to corroborate his thesis. |